This page will be updated frequently as I learn of new books (hopefully from you)! Consider it a permanent work in progress. Also, not everyone interprets things the same way, so by all means, if you disagree with a recommendation - please do comment. Other readers may like to hear the con-argument to help them make choices.
Good Books for Young Girls
(and Boys, who also should know that girls matter)
While there are some great books that are explicitly feminist or deal with responding to what others say girls can and can’t do, I’m not actually a huge fan of those. I guess because right now my dd and ds have have no reason to think that boys and girls aren’t equally important, interesting, and capable. So, right now I don’t feel a need to address thes issues with them. Instead, I look for non-sexist/stereotyped books that are centered around girls who are doing interesting things. Who would think that they would be so hard to find? If they are brave, clever, strong — even better. Most of the books listed here are of this variety, the balance are books that may not feature a particularly fantastic female character, but open the gender box a bit…
The Dot by Peter Reynolds
This is a great little story about a girl named Vashti who thinks she can’t draw, is encouraged by a teacher, goes crazy expressing herself, becomes recognized, and then encourages an admirer to find the courage to try as well. Great illustrations - just lovely. I started this book with my dd when she was 2.5. I think anyone under about 6 would enjoy it.
Sally Jean the Bicycle Queen by Cari Best and Christine Davenier
This is probably my favorite. It is a GREAT story about a little girl who loves to ride her bike. As she grows her parents raise the handle bars and seat (her Mom even uses tools), but eventually she outgrows it completely. Heartbroken, she has to figure out what to do. She tries raising money by teaching other kids to fix their own bikes, but eventually uses materials she finds around to build her own new bike. Obviously, Sally Jean is not your average female book character, but she isn’t just a good role model - she’s FUN - always rhyming poems about how great she is on her bike. It’s recommended for kids ages 4-8, but my dd loved it at 3 as well (it is fairly long though, so it might depend on the child).
Brave Charlotte by Anu Stohner and Heinrike Wilson
So, okay, this is a book about a sheep, but Charlotte is so brave, adventurous, and confident — it’s well worth it! This book is about young sheep Charlotte who takes risks and worries the older sheep. In the end, when the shepherd is injured, it is Charlotte who saves the day and earns the respect of the rest of the flock. The book is designated for 4-8 year olds, but a 3 year old could certainly enjoy it.
The Mommy Book and The Daddy Book by Todd Parr
Todd Parr is the king of progressive socialization (maybe you know his Peace Book or The Family Book or It’s Okay to Be Different) and here he offers two great books that show the range of Mommies and Daddies respectively. “Some Mommies Fly Kites.” “Some Mommies Fly Planes.” - you get the idea. Both books are jubilantly colorful in illustration, and playful and diverse in text. I love these books as gifts for new parents. They are recommended for ages 4-8, but imho it’s much better for 1.5 - 3 year olds.
Dora Saves the Prince by Alison Inches and Brian McGee
While I’m not a big fan of the cross promotion fiesta empire that is Dora, I couldn’t possibly resist a bilingual Latina adventurer who rescues a Prince instead of being rescued! Has clear reusable stickers for play. Says 4-8, 2-4 is probably better. Go Dora!
When Catherine the Great and I Were Eight by Cari Best and Giselle Potter
This is an adorable book about Sara, her Grandmother Catherine, and their neighbors. It’s a simple story about being stuck in traffic on the way from the city to the beach, but it’s real and playful, and I can’t get enough of this crew. Not particularly feminist, but a nice female-centered story about a girl who enjoys her Russian Grandma.
There’s a Dragon Downstairs by Hilary McKay and Amanda Harvey
In this quiet book, a girl named Sophie is convinced that a dragon comes in at night while she is trying to sleep and she tries several tricks to apprehend the dragon herself. In the end, it’s only the cat, but it’s nice to see a story where a girl feels afraid and takes matters into her own hands. Ages 4-8.
Stella Star of the Sea and Stella Queen of the Snow by Marie-Louise Gay
These two charmers are about spirited Stella, who is a delight - she is adventurous, bold, and relishes the expertise bestowed upon her by virtue of being the older sister to a younger brother who is far more risk averse. In both books, Stella guides her brother Sam through new experiences that intimidate him, leading by example - playful and a little reckless. Sam follows along, asking myriad questions. She answers every one, whether the answer is correct or not. Stella is an infectious character. I hope to be more like her one day, myself! Recommended for ages 3-8, but I think most children over 5 would be looking for a little more, and it could certainly keep the attention of many 2 year olds.
My Friends by Taro Gomi
This is an adorable board book in which a pig-tailed Asian girl shows us what she has learned from each of her friends. “I learned to climb from my friend the monkey” “I learned to read from my friends the books” and so on. The watercolor illustrations are delightful plus we see a girl as the center of attention doing all sorts of things, both active and gentle. I love it. Too long for little bitty babies IMHO, but great for your 18 month old - 3 year old. Adorable!
Since my son is an infant, I haven’t yet begun the search for books that show boys in anti-sexist ways — if you have favorites, please let me know. I’m sure many are interested in your suggestions. I know I am!
Anti-Consumerist Books
The Gift of Nothing by Patrick McDonnell
This is a sweet book about Mooch the cat and Earl the dog. When Mooch wishes to commemorate Earl’s birthday, he realizes that Earl already has everything (a bed, a chew toy, and a bowl), he sets out to buy him “nothing.” In the end, he gives an empty box and the two of them enjoy each others’ company, and all that nature has to offer. Though this is a very short book, the conceptual elements make it best for 5-8 year olds.
Three Cheers for Catherine the Great by Cari Best and Giselle Potter
This is another book about Sarah and her Russian Grandma and all of their delightful neighbors. In this story, they are throwing a party for Catherine (the Grandmother) and work to comply with her request for “no presents.” They each give her a lovely “no present,” one is a dance, one is a song, and Sarah offers to teach her to read and write in English. The book shows what fun nonmaterial gifts are and brings to life the immigrant experience at the same time. I love it. Ages 4-8.
The Sneetches by Dr. Seuss
Oh how we love the Sneetches in our house and whether you want to understand it as story about racism or the dangers of competition or as anti-consumerist is up to you, but there is no doubt that this can be used to talk about status goods (be they clothing or toys or sneakers…) and the way trends are followed to the benefit of no one but the corporations selling the goods. Dr. Seuss gets it right and of course with great fun. Ages 4-8.
supadiscomama
August 26, 2007 | 3:38 pm1
Another great book for girls is The Paper Bag Princess. It has a similar storyline to the Dora book, but sans the “crosspromotional fiesta.” The princess, wearing a paper bag dress (the dragon burned up all of her clothes), rescues the prince by outsmarting the dragon. When he sees her, the prince tells her to come back when she looks “like a princess.” She tells him that he may look like a prince, but he’s actually a bum–”and she didn’t marry him, after all.” Great fun. I’m terrible at guessing the appropriate age for a book–maybe 4-8?
Brandi
September 8, 2007 | 8:51 am2
I have two girls, 6 and 4. When my oldest was around 5, I started reading chapter books to them. You can’t go wrong with Ramona Quimby! Actually, at the time I was surprised that my younger one (then three or four) was also willing to sit through a chapter read aloud. They also really enjoyed the Little House series. Both involve spunky girls and, best of all, aren’t “branded products” for the most part.
Jennifer
October 3, 2007 | 10:46 pm3
It’s so hard to find kids books that even have little girls as a main character. When my daughter was smaller, I used to change the names of the characters & all the he’s to she’s…now that she’s bigger, I just have to look harder for books. Thanks for your suggestions.
Nathaniel Tapley
November 23, 2007 | 1:22 pm4
I haven’t read it for a few years (just 20 or so…) but I remember Shel Silverstein’s ‘The Giving Tree’ having a potent anti-consumerist message (or maybe it was just generally counter-cultural).
Actually, thinking back I’m not sure it’s as clear as that. I remember feeling very sorry for the tree, and quite cross with the boy, but the happy ending, I suppose, doesn’t really slam any anti-consumerist message home.
Still, I loved it, and, as a child (and just now) it made me think…
Marc
November 23, 2007 | 3:53 pm5
I second “The Paper Bag Princess” by Robert Munsch. As a dad, I love that story and read it to my 4 year old daughter. Interestingly, I have heard from others who have used this story in the classroom that some girls think the princess made thewrong choice at the end (walking away from the thankless prince). So it’s a great story to read and then ask the child what she (or he) would have done.
I agree with Jennifer that it is very hard to find good stories with strong young girls as the lead. Your list will provide a starting point for me. Off to the library we go!
eszter
November 23, 2007 | 10:00 pm6
I just went to our local Barnes and Noble and looked for most of the books listed here. The woman at the children’s section who was certainly trying to be helpful had never heard of some of these, which itself is interesting. They did have some of these books, and additional books by the authors listed here. I thought the Gift of Nothing was adorable!
magistra
November 26, 2007 | 10:20 am7
For younger boys, there are several storybooks on boys and food/cooking (for example, Meredith Hooper, ‘Honey Biscuits’ and Vivian French’s Oliver books). Henrietta Baekow, ‘Alfie’s Angels’ is all about a boy who wants to be an angel in the school play. I suspect some of the many books for older siblings on having a new baby have boys helping with babycare.
From my rather out-dated knowledge of fiction for older children, I think there isn’t much that explicitly has boys doing sterotypically ‘female’ activities. But there are quite a few authors who do have boy characters who aren’t would-be alpha-males. Some I remember are Mary O’Hara’s ‘My Friend Flicka’ books and the sequels, Rosemary Sutcliffe’s historical novels and K. M Peyton’s books.
nicegirlphd
November 26, 2007 | 10:24 pm8
Thanks for the great recommendations! I have a 3yo boy, but I am tempted to buy all those books for young girls that you recommended!
I also like the Olivia books (for younger readers) — they are funny for the adults, too.
mamagenerica
November 28, 2007 | 9:36 am9
Hi there, one more subverted-princess picture book that both I and my daughters love is The Tough Princess by Martin Waddell — the illustrations are by Patrick Benson who also collaborated with Waddell on The Owl Babies and they’re perfect. The book is hilarious as well as subversive
Erin Olson
November 28, 2007 | 12:55 pm10
We also enjoy “There’s Something in my Attic” by Mercer Mayer. It’s about a little girl who thinks there is a nightmare in her attic so she goes up and catches it herself.
“A fire engine for Ruthie” is a good one, too, if a little preachy. A girl named Ruthie goes to stay with her grandmother, who has only dolls, dress-up clothes, etc. Ruthie notices the neighbor boy has cool toys like fire engines, trains, etc, and Ruthie and her grandmother go buy some toys like that for themselves. Sometimes I wish, though, that a story could just have a little girl who likes to play with fire engines without pointing out that it’s anything unusual.
mom
November 28, 2007 | 4:41 pm11
Thank you for these great new ideas!!!!
k2
December 4, 2007 | 5:19 pm12
Another good, funny twist on the traditional princess story is ‘Igraine The Brave’ by Cornelia Funke.
The Jim half of "Academic couple (Sandi and Jim)"
December 15, 2007 | 2:58 am13
I haven’t read the Pippi Longstocking books of Astrid Lindgren
or the Miss Bianca books of Margery Sharp in over thirty years,
so I can’t say for sure that they meet all of a progressive parent’s requirements, but they’d probably be worth checking out.
(True, Miss Bianca did get Disney-ified in the late 70s, but a
Google search for a “Miss Bianca lunchbox” returned the
reassuring reply “Your search did not match any documents”.)
As a boy, I also enjoyed the heroines of “No Flying in the House”,
“Time at the Top”, and “Caddy Woodlawn”. And I’m sure I would
have liked “Mathilda” too (though I didn’t read that book until a
couple of years ago).
Jim
Jackie
March 26, 2008 | 3:59 pm14
One book I would like to toss your way as a great example of a young girl as a central character with plenty of fortitude is “A Wrinkle in Time.”
Not a young child’s book to be sure, but I had a copy when i was a young girl and read it so many times it fell apart.
Same thing for my 2 children. What is wonderful is that they are now to the ages where they are grown and thinking about children……and when they think back on favorite books, that one is at the top of the list
outside the (toy) box » Smartypants Holiday: Givin’ and Gettin’ or What Would Jesus Buy?
November 18, 2007 | 4:17 pm15
[…] Anti-Sexist/Anti-Consumerist Children’s Books […]
Noli Irritare Leones » Blog Archive » Blogwatch: Sex-starved terrorists? Deadly New York City? Don’t be so sure.
November 26, 2007 | 12:09 pm16
[…] at Crooked Timber, Is there a fire truck gene? points out a list of children’s books which would have been useful to me if I hadn’t found it right after I’d finished buying […]